THE COACHING CONVERSATION 02
Why real estate
coaching fails.
A coaching call is a start. You need experience, practical systems and the work to put them in place.
Get to the point
THE SHORT ANSWER
Real estate coaching can fail when the advice isn’t connected to an operating business or never makes it into yours. You need a coach with relevant experience, practical systems and a plan you’re prepared to put to work.
When I was doing 50 deals a year as a solo agent, I knew I couldn’t keep building my business around working every hour. I started building a team and the systems to support it. I wrote about that experience in my 2024 article on burnout and building a team.
That’s why I care about coaching you can put to work. You don’t need another conversation that ends with a list of things you might do someday. You need to know what you’re going to change and how you’ll follow through.
A real operating business
The coach is not actively operating in today’s market.
Real estate changes. The conversations you have with buyers and sellers change. If your coach’s experience is all from years ago, ask how they know their advice still applies.
I want you to ask what their operating business is doing now. How do they generate opportunities? What does follow-up look like? How do they train their people? You’re not looking for a speech about the good old days. You’re looking for someone who can talk about the work.
“What is your real estate business doing in the market today, and how does that shape what you teach?”
Production beyond yours
The coach’s business is not selling more homes than yours.
If you want to build a bigger real estate business, I believe your coach needs to sell more homes than you. You want to learn from someone who has experience handling the opportunities, people and decisions that come with growth.
Ask for the current numbers and the period they cover. Are you comparing the coach’s individual sales with yours, or their team’s production with yours? Ask what role the coach plays in that operation and how they’ll teach you what they’ve learned.
Production matters, but it doesn’t replace the ability to teach. You need both current experience and a way to put that experience into your own business.
“How many homes do you and your team sell, and what can you show me from that experience?”
Systems, not slogans
There are no systems behind the advice.
“Follow up with your leads” sounds like good advice. But what do you say when you call? Where do you record the conversation? When is the next follow-up? Who is responsible for making it?
That’s the difference between a suggestion and something you can actually use. In my training, I talk about giving a lead a clear outcome: an appointment, a follow-up or a decision that it isn’t a fit. If there’s a follow-up, give it a next action. Don’t leave it sitting there and hope you remember.
Ask a prospective coach to show you how they approach lead follow-up, training or a listing presentation. The system may need to fit your market and your business, but they should be able to explain the work.
“Can you show me a system you use and explain how I would put it into my business?”
Implementation
The plan never makes it into the business.
I’ve seen how easy it is to spend all your time working in your business and never make time to work on it. A good idea from a coaching call won’t change anything if it stays in your notebook.
Pick the problem you’re going to work on. If it’s lead follow-up, look at your existing leads, decide on the next action and practise the conversation. Put time in your calendar to do the work. Then look at what happened and what needs to change.
Your coach can help you make a plan and stay accountable. You still have to show up and do the work.
“What am I going to put in place first, and when will we review it?”
Accountability and fit
There is no useful accountability, or the coaching is a poor fit.
Coaching needs to fit the business you have and the business you want to build. A solo agent and a team leader might be working on very different problems. Ask your coach how they’ll decide where to start with you.
Then track the activity that matters to the problem. How many conversations did you have? How many appointments did you book? What happened to the people who weren’t ready yet? Those numbers give you something useful to talk about when you meet.
I often say, “I should not be more excited about your business than you are.” Your coach should help you move forward, but the commitment has to come from you.
“What will we track, and how will you help me when I’m not following through?”
BEFORE YOU CHOOSE A COACH
Ask questions before you commit.
- What does your operating business sell today?
- What systems do you use, and can you teach them?
- What is included, what does it cost, and who will coach me?
- How will we turn the plan into action and review progress?
You’re investing in your business. Ask for the details you need to make a decision that’s right for you.
The assumptions to challenge before you choose your next coach.
